Monday, April 20, 2009

Why I'm pretty sure I think I'm pro-Life. Maybe. I'm getting there.

When I was in high school, I was a Leftist. So far Left, it makes me sick thinking about it now. I would attend protests calling for the destruction of the Jewish state, and for former President Bush to be tried and hanged for war crimes. I went to a high school that didn't exactly discourage this sort of thing. I think of it as Indoctrination High (David Horowitz's new book, Indoctrination U: http://www.amazon.com/Indoctrination-U-Against-Academic-Freedom/dp/1594032378/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1240232313&sr=8-1 ).

I was a Leftist before I started there, however my level of political interest was limited until my senior year of high school. The only thing my mother voted on was the issue of abortion, even on the state and local level. If you didn't support a woman's right to choose, she didn't support you. Slowly, starting in college, uncharacteristically, I moved to the right. It started with two books: A History of Israel by Howard Sachar, a dry historical accounting of Israeli history from WWI to the present. I saw the Middle East, for the first time, in an un-biased light, and it made me wonder why the Left was hellbent on defending a people that tried to commit genocide against another ("throw the Jews into the sea!" was exclaimed during the War of Independence in 1947). The Jews were always eager to give land and peace whenever possible, but were often thwarted by the Arabs who were insistent on the destruction of the Jewish State, and nothing less. A second book, Atlas Shrugged, by Ayn Rand showed me the future of a socialist state, and made me totally reevaluate my economic leanings. Something that I've held onto, however, was my social Leftism. Until now.

Like many other bits of my Leftism, I never quite understood how people believed in G-d and religion. I thought it was a crock. There's a famous quote by the wrestler-turned-Governor Jesse Ventura, "Religion is a crutch for the weak-minded." That was my truth. I always self-identified as Jewish, and culturally and historically sided with the Jewish people. The G-d part of it, however, I didn't quite buy. It wasn't until a biology class my first year of college that something clicked. The perfect way that everything worked, how every cell and every system of the body perfectly complimented another, the thought struck me. "This is no accident." Thus started my venture into the world of religion, only this time I wasn't an outsider looking in.

So what does this have to do with abortion? During this same class, I started to see how much we are impacted by our DNA. How little nurture has so little to do with who we are, and how much it as to do with nature. Why did some siblings in the Holocaust survive when others did not? Why, in the face of adversity do some flourish and some fail? Partially it is to do with how we are raised, but mostly, it's how the genome falls. There is much less personal choice than most people feel comfortable with admitting. To me the argument that "it's just a bunch of cells" fell short of the reality. That bunch of cells was a potential person, with complexities and potential, just like a full-term fetus. It is no less a person at day 9 than it is at month 9. It astounds me to look at my baby cousin, to see how quickly her personality formed, long before she was aware of her own hands. Why are some babies "happy babies" and some miniature Scrooges? It's in our DNA, it's inherent.

In the summer of 2007, I spent three months in Cambodia. While I was there, teaching at an English school for adults, one of our students offered to let the female teachers come to her clinic, where she was performing abortions, to watch one. I was the only one to decline. The others I think saw it as a woman's right to choose in action. Each came back pale, and couldn't really speak about what they saw. It was, I think, much more violent and graphic than they expected. By the time the fetus was big enough to be vacuumed out, it already looked like a baby. Probably because it was.

After that point, I decided, personally, I would never do that to myself or my body, and more importantly, to my child. I decided, however, it was a personal choice that every woman had the right to make over her own body. Who are we to regulate that? But the thought occurred to me, once that embryo is formed, is that really her body anymore, or is it that it becomes outside of her control? Should it be one person's choice to end another's life? I don't think so anymore.

And what of the argument: they're going to do it anyway, let's give women a safe alternative? Do we give guns to convicted murderers, because, hey, they're going to do it anyway? No, we do not facilitate crimes just because of their likelihood of occurring. You can do it, in end we can't stop you but we shouldn't be offering a helping hand. Nor should we be providing tax-dollars to do it, Mr. Obama (read: Mexico City Policy).

We, as women, do have a choice. The choice is to not become pregnant in the first place. With the ready availability of birth control pills, condoms, IUDs, no woman in the United States of America has any business getting pregnant when we don't want to. (And yes, I know that I am ignoring the issue of rape and incest, however that is quite honestly an entirely new ball of wax, and the amount of abortions those cases actually account for is really quite small.) The issue becomes what happens when we do get pregnant accidentally.

My biggest issue with the Left is a complete lack of accountability, a complete lack of personal responsibility. We expect other people (read: the government) to provide our health care, to help us on defaulted mortgages on homes we could never afford in the first place, to pay for the retirements we never prepared for. However, taking ownership of these mistakes is the first step in making them right. We should not run from them, or pretend as though others should solve them. This should not doom children to death before life, nor to homes that never wished for them in the first place (pull a Juno, open the PennySaver, there are plenty of couples that would do anything for a child to love).

So, to echo the title of this entry. I'm pretty sure I'm pro-Life. I'm getting there. It's raining outside today, and I just hope that my mother doesn't pull a Zeus and strike me with lightening. That's probably the only thing stopping me from saying, yes, I am pro-Life. My first memory with my mother is driving down the highway on Long Island and giving protesters at an abortion clinic the finger. It's a happy memory. I'm almost able to settle myself with who I am now, to what I was then.

To all the Leftists reading this (I doubt any have made it this far), watch this:
http://www.catholicvote.com/

12 comments:

Michael said...

Great post.

Amit said...

I made it to the bottom. Even though you won't twat with me anymore.

Jenni said...

This is a very eloquent recitation of your journey to find your personal truth. If you engage in premarital sex, you have probably experienced anxious days where you wonder if you have become pregnant. Sometimes these scares come from encounters with a Man of the Moment and not necessarily with the Man of Your Dreams. If that has happened to you, I am almost sure the possibility of an abortion crossed your mind if only as a thought to discard as an option for you. I have had a moment or two of my own and know I could not have an abortion, ever. But you and I also had one other thing. A choice. Pro-Choice does NOT say Pro-Abortion. It says choice.

You are making the decision to be Pro-Life as is your right. But you making that decision for you, not the rest of us. Why would you deny the right to make life choices to all because it is the right choice for you? Pro-Life for all will do that.

Bethany said...

But once that embryo is created, I argue, is that a choice for you to make anymore? Who has the power to take a life from another? Not to sound all preachy, but only G-d has that right.

Ally said...

Bethany, as a Pro-life Christian who once had pro "choice" views in high school as well, i couldn't help but cry tears of joy, solidarity & peace when reading such a profound, courageous & honest post.

I was raised in church & was always taught that when we live our lives in obedience to God's Word our greatest reward in heaven is God's words of appreciation: "Well done thy good and faithful servant."

I can say without reservation or hesitation that our God spoke those words in your name today in honor of your decision to protect his greatest & most precious gift.

Thank you for such a beautifully eloquent post and for your courage in sharing this with others. May it bless many others in the way it blessed me today.

Grace and Peace,
Ally

PS - really enjoying following your tweets (ally_ugadawg)

Jennifer @ Conversion Diary said...

Just found this post via Twitter. Great, great stuff. I can relate to so much of what you wrote, especially your feelings about how people you know would react if they found out you were pro-life.

I "came out" as being pro-life in an article I wrote last year (here if you have any interest) and got some "WTF?!" calls from my friends when they saw it since I had always been staunchly pro-choice. :)

Anyway, thanks again for a great post.

Simon Synett said...

Bethany, really impressive. I mean your honesty, and your ability to take that scary step out of yourself and look reflexively at your convictions.
You've got a lot to teach...keep going.
Best,
Simon

Jenni said...

That is your decision. You have made a choice. Allow everyone else the right to their own journey to come to their own decision. For many, an embryo that cannot sustain life outside the womb is just a promise, not a person. Do not impose your very personal decision on all others. Allow them to make their own for their own reasons.

Anonymous said...

Thanks so much for sharing your story and I give you a lot of credit to coming to your (almost) decision without actually being 'with child.' When I was 32, I became pregnant and my career was really taking off, student loans just paid off and I wasn't married. Among other things that are too long to get into in the 'comments' section, a song really helped me come to the decision to choose life .. "To Zion" by Lauryn Hill. Listen to it sometime. By the way, my son is an absolute beautiful 10 yr old gifted child ... writing music, writing stories .. the day he was born, I was so blessed and honored. My husband and I have 2 other children as well. We're truly blessed. My best friend said to me when I was pregnant .. "if you have the baby, you'll never regred it; if you don't you most definitely will someday." Best advice I ever got!

Anonymous said...

Me again .. don't be discouraged by people who are put off by your expressing your journey. You may want to look up a writer/author/blogger Gi Gi James. She's on MySpace under 'tcoo' and also blogs for alphawomen.com. I heard her speak about being pro-life on the radio yesterday .. loved her message and she took a lot of crap from vicious caller!

Amit Mistry said...

I've got some time so I'd like to elaborate my point beyond my amazingly sophomoric humor - which I'm sure you miss terribly so.

The day you posted this I for some reason also was thinking about abortion on the drive to school. Unsurprisingly, our positions differ but not by much.

I think abortion is a really terrible medical procedure that I am not for. I find it a bit sickening to be truthful. At the same time, I don't feel like it's something that should be against the law. In lieu of abortions, I'd much rather people give the babies up for adoption (not sure if you were being tongue in cheek with the Juno reference) or, you know, not get pregnant in the first place.

It's just that it does serve a purpose at times. There are the few instances (rape, incest, medical) where opposition isn't as fervent. The gray area is when the baby would be born to a single mother with five other kids and a drug habit. I'd think that the kids would eventually get taken away from the mother, but until that happens the child would be in a very unfortunate situation.

I've got to get to class soon, but basically here's how I feel about it: I think abortion should only be allowed early in a pregnancy, both parents should be notified (as well as parents of teenagers if that's the case), all efforts should be made for adoption instead (and avoiding the pregnancy in the first place) and doctors and nurses shouldn't be compelled to perform an abortion if they don't wish.

And on a political note, I dislike how abortion is used.

Jenni said...

Any thoughts on the "morning-after pill"?